Democratic Party bars ‘lazy’ pro-LGBT judge from election ticket

By Julia Marsh, Carl Campanile and Laura Italiano
August 31, 2016


Democratic Party bars ‘lazy’ pro-LGBT judge from election ticket
Appellate Term Justice Doris Ling-Cohan
Photo: Don Halasy

A Manhattan judge who is considered a hero in the LGBT community has been barred from running on the Democratic ticket, a move that virtually dooms her re-election prospects in November.

The county Democratic Party’s judicial screening panel took the highly unusual step Tuesday night of not reapproving the judge, Appellate Term Justice Doris Ling-Cohan.

“Attached is a copy of the 2016 Supreme Court Independent Judicial Screening Panel Report. You will note that Judge Doris Ling-Cohan is not on the list of incumbent judges found to Merit Continuation In Office,” Curtis Arluck and Louise Dankberg, chair and co-chair of the party’s judiciary committee, said in an email to party officials Wednesday night.


The panel found the judge was “lazy,” and “slow” in handling her caseload, multiple sources said.

“For a sitting New York County justice not to be reappointed is a first, to my knowledge,” said Dankberg.

“This is very unusual. This is a shocker — you’ve told me shocking news,” said longtime Manhattan judicial blogger and watchdog Alan Flacks.

Two years ago, the Chinatown-raised Ling-Cohan became the first woman of Asian descent in the state to be appointed to an appellate court; in 2002 she became the first Asian woman to be elected to state Supreme Court.

But she is best known for her decision, in a five-couple class-action suit in 2005, to approve the right of same-sex couples to marry. She was the first trial judge in the state to do so, though her decision was quickly reversed on appeal.

Rejecting Ling-Cohan was “a slap in the face” to the LGBT community, said gay Democratic district leader Allen Roskoff.

“Judge Ling-Cohan is a great judge,” Roskoff said. “She is a hero and needs to be championed and revered.”

Typically, the party rubber-stamps an incumbent judge’s re-election.

But sources told The Post that the screening panel’s membership of nearly two dozen Manhattan lawyers and legal association reps turned thumbs down on Ling-Cohan out of a consensus that she was a lackluster judge.

“Somebody had it in for her, and there were five Asian-Americans on the panel who did not speak out for her,” said one expert with knowledge of the decision.

Ling-Cohan’s reputation is “as one of the worst judges — non-productive, lazy, not hard-working, disorganized, takes a lot of time off, late with decisions,” the source said.

When she moved up to the Appellate Term in 2014, she left behind a Supreme Court backlog of hundreds of unfinished cases and undecided motions, said another source.

Still another source said that two or three votes were taken Tuesday night, “to try to persuade people to change their vote” and approve her — but the efforts failed.

“It’s a s—ty thing to do this to a sitting judge,” that source added. “It’s an unwritten rule that you really don’t find a sitting judge all of a sudden after 14 years unqualified, unless they’re an ax murderer or a pedophile.”

Ling-Cohan did not respond Wednesday night to email and phone messages requesting comment.

In July, a Brooklyn Supreme Court judge with 25 years’ experience on the bench was similarly found unqualified by a Democratic Party judicial screening panel in that borough.

That judge, Justice Laura Jacobson, has vowed to appeal the decision.






  1. Hon. Eric Adams
  2. George Arzt
  3. Lance Bass
  4. John Blair
  5. Mark Benoit
  6. Hon. Rodneyse Bichotte
  7. Hon. Jonathan Bing
  8. Erik Bottcher
  9. Robin Byrd
  10. Hon. Gale Brewer
  11. Christian Campbell
  12. Gus Christensen
  13. Hon. Martin Connor
  14. Hon. Jon Cooper
  15. Wilson Cruz
  16. Hon. Laurie Cumbo
  17. Alan Cumming
  18. Valorie Curry
  19. Michael Czaczkes
  20. Hon. Bill de Blasio
  21. Jon Del Giorno
  22. Aries Dela Cruz
  23. Kyan Douglas
  24. Hon. Daniel Dromm
  25. James Duff
  26. Hon. Ronnie Eldridge
  27. Hon. Rafael Espinal
  28. Hon. Herman Farrell
  29. Hon. Alan Fleishman
  30. Hon. Dan Garodnick
  31. Dan Gettleman
  32. Jason Goldman
  33. Emily Jane Goodman
  34. Hon. Mark Green
  35. Tony Hoffmann
  36. Hon. Brad Hoylman
  37. Binn Jakupi
  38. Hon. Letitia James
  39. Hon. Corey Johnson
  40. Camille Joseph
  41. Phillip Keane
  42. Greg Lambert
  43. Dodge Landesman
  44. Phillip McCarthy
  45. Matt McMorrow
  46. Michael Mallon
  47. Mike C. Manning
  48. David Mansur
  49. Cathy Marino-Thomas
  50. Troy Masters
  51. Hon. Carlos Menchaca
  52. Hon. Rosie Mendez
  53. John Cameron Mitchell
  54. Donny Moss
  55. Barry Mullineaux
  56. Hon. Paul Newell
  57. Denis O'Hare
  58. Noah Pfefferbilt
  59. Josue Pierre
  60. Bob Pontarelli
  61. Billy Porter
  62. Hon. Keith Powers
  63. Randy Rainbow
  64. Hon. Jenifer Rajkumar
  65. Hon. Gustavo Rivera
  66. Hon. Helen Rosenthal
  67. Maer Roshan
  68. Toby Russo
  69. Bill Samuels
  70. James Sansum
  71. Scott Sartiano
  72. Hon. Arthur Schwartz
  73. Lynn Schulman
  74. Frank Selvaggi
  75. Rev. Al Sharpton
  76. Hon. Jo Anne Simon
  77. Tom Smith
  78. Anne Strahle
  79. Hon. Scott Stringer
  80. Wayne Sunday
  81. Hon. Bill Thompson
  82. JD Thompson
  83. Hon. Matt Titone
  84. Hon. Ritchie Torres
  85. Sam Underwood
  86. Jessica Walter
  87. Patricia Nell Warren
  88. Wil Weder
  89. Seth Weissman
  90. Mel Wymore
  91. Emma Wolfe
  92. Hon. Keith Wright
  93. Zephyr Teachout